Skip to main content

Waterproof? Maybe. Smudgeproof? I Think Not.

Ever since high school, I have been a liquid/gel eye liner addict. I switched on and off between products, and until recently, I've relied on MAC Fluidline in Blacktrack. Here's what the MAC site says about this product:
Ultra-smooth, Fluidline’s gel formula provides the precision of a liquid liner with a silkier, softer finish. Goes on “foolproof” with a brush in an easy dip-and-stroke action. Long-wearing. Smudge-proof.
I have to tell you, that description is on the money. It goes on like a breeze, dries in a ziff and is very smudge resistant - even in the humidity. What it makes no promise of being, however, is waterproof. Browsing my local Sephora, I came across Make Up For Ever's Waterproof Eye Liner. Here's what Sephora says about it:
Swim, sweat, and tears are no match for MAKE UP FOR EVER's Waterproof Eyeliner. The durable formula lasts all day ....
Not bad right? So, while I had no complaints with my Fluidline, I thought I'd give this a shot. I did a little research at Sephora, and apparently it's the only waterproof liquid liner they sell. Ok, so as you know, I am no novice to liquid liner - I am, after all, a self-confessed liner junkie. So when I tried this out at home, my first observation was that the brush tends to come out over-saturated with product, which means you have to carefully brush excess off (and waste it in the process) before applying. I applied the liner and it sure did produce a rich, velvety, black line. So far so good. I made sure to let my lids dry before I left the house - no smudges in sight.

Oddly enough, however, about two hours later, while the line itself was as black and pigmented as ever, I now found to my shock, a second line near my brow bone. Now I have to tell you, in all my years of experimenting with high end and drug store liquid and gel liners, never have I had this happen! To be fair, I gave this product a couple more shots, but no dice. One thing I do not need to worry about is major liner smudge - hell, I'd rather the liner rub off and vanish than walk around with four lines instead of two. So, I'll be returning to my trusty matte friend Blacktrack, and its more day-time friendly sidekick, Blitz & Glitz.


Renu said…
Have you ever tried MAc..powder.mineralize skinfinish natural? I think their natural is different from ours.
desipolitan said…
Oh yes, Renu. I know what you mean. Unfortunately, I find with most cosmetics brands, the range of shades and what's "natural" is not totally applicable to desi complexions. Nars makes excellent foundations in a very wide range of colors...might be worth a look.
Anonymous said…
If you're after a waterproof/smudge/sweat proof liquid liner try Eyeliner Tattoo by kji&co. I bought mine at Sasa in Malaysia .. if anything this stuff is impossible to remove! Here's the website
desipolitan said…
Ooo. Thanks for the tip 'Anonymous'! I'm officially on a quest to find this stuff - it sounds perfect.

Popular posts from this blog

Meet Queen Jetsun Pema of Bhutan

The young, beautiful, and fashionable Queen of Bhutan, a country secluded from the world's limelight due to its remoteness, has already been generating a stir ever since her marriage to the King and her rise to the position of Queen Consort. She is a powerhouse in her own right, and much loved by the Bhutanese people. However, on a fun and superficial level, she has also drawn favorable comparisons to the Duchess of Cambridge, so much so, that she is sometimes referred to as the "Kate Middleton of the Himalayas".
So who is this Himalayan Queen? At 25-years-old, she is the youngest Queen Consort in the world. Like Kate, she was a commoner (though with an aristocratic lineage) and the daughter of a pilot. She is fashionable, athletic, and holds a university arts background. Additionally, she herself is a brand new mum, having recently given birth to a baby boy.
As with Wills and Kate, the King and Queen of Bhutan have always shown great respect for their country's cult…

Looking for a DiorShow Extase dupe

Getting 3 kiddos fed, dressed, and out the door on time on school mornings, is challenging on a good day. Between prepping breakfasts, packing lunches, double checking bags for homework, and generally refereeing Big A and S while simultaneously holding or nursing Little A, means I have precious little time to make myself presentable. As a result, mascara has taken the front and center stage of my makeup routine for rushed mornings because who has time to carefully paint on eyeliner?!
1. DiorShow Extase (discontinued) 2. IT Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing Mascara
I was crushed when Dior discontinued their Extase mascara. I adored it. The brush had the perfect shape, and unlike DiorShow or Blackout, this formulation was amenable to multiple, clump-free coats. Unfortunately, none of the current offerings in the Dior mascara lineup feature a similar brush to Extase. IT Cosmetics offered a comparable brush and sounded like it might be a good dupe. On the positive side, the m…

Two Faced Mascara Melt-Off

**UPDATED** We all love mascara that doesn't budge, but who enjoys nightly battles with mascara removal? Not I. Which is why I was excited to give this product a whirl. It promises quick, easy, and effective mascara removal. I simply applied a coat to my lashes using the kind of wand you would expect for lower lash mascaras. I let the product remain on my lashes as I washed my face (approx. two minutes). I used a cotton pad soaked in my favorite eye-makeup remover to gently sweep off the mascara.
The Mascara Melt-Off definitely speeds up the mascara removal process, with significantly less tugging and rubbing of lashes. I felt that the results were a more thorough mascara removal than makeup remover alone.

That said, the directions stated to use a cotton pad to wipe off the mascara; but I found that you most definitely need to soak the pad in your usual remover. Also, I should note that I tested it on non-waterproof mascara. I have no idea how effective it would be in the case of …